(11-10-2019, 04:32 PM)Mad Squad Wrote:

(11-10-2019, 02:22 PM)Sniffer Dog Wrote:

(08-10-2019, 01:57 PM)Alf Wrote:

(08-10-2019, 12:41 PM)Salvatore Matrecano Wrote: Tend to agree with this, probably more than one flash of brilliance every 3 games, more like 3 brilliant passes every game but then he is totally anonymous for the rest of it and as has been said would like to see him do a 90 min performance. We want him to dictate play, be at the heart of every forward move.

Are we being too harsh, we are obsessed with his price tag but forget he is only 22?
The other point is do you want to replace him with an Osborn type who runs non stop, at the expense of that one moment that opens a defence? To be honest that one moment is why I go to football matches.

Im as conflicted as everyone else I think!

Good summary.

I rate him, but think 13m was way too much, and that he should have been 4-6m at most.

But that's irrelavant now. At 22 he's still got bags of time to grow, and he's also a player who'll suit the Prem way more than the hustle & bustle of this league.

The key thing is finding him a position. The role AK had planned for him isn't the one we have planned now.

We didn't pay 13m for him and I don't care what the next accounts say. That is why we employ Sam Gordon.

Interesting comment Sniffer. Care to elaborate?

(18-10-2019, 07:03 AM)Duncan Mckenzie Wrote: Carvalho or Silva versus Wigan or both?

As things stand I would go with Silva for the first 70 minutes and then replace him with Carvalho.

(19-10-2019, 11:23 AM)TheGreenMan Wrote: Carvalho every day in his rightful position just behind Grabban.

Even tho I thought he had his best game for the club against Brentford since signing overall I think he’s been disappointing.
But to be fair to him he’s still getting used to playing in a foreign country and in a different type of league and we all know he has got that quality in him and I have every confidence in him that he’ll come good.

(19-10-2019, 12:10 PM)Sniffer Dog Wrote:

(19-10-2019, 11:23 AM)TheGreenMan Wrote: Carvalho every day in his rightful position just behind Grabban.

Even tho I thought he had his best game for the club against Brentford since signing overall I think he’s been disappointing.
But to be fair to him he’s still getting used to playing in a foreign country and in a different type of league and we all know he has got that quality in him and I have every confidence in him that he’ll come good.

How much longer is that excuse going to be trotted out though?

I like Carvalho, I think he will play in the PL one day but right now I want to see more from him. 4 goals in 41 appearances the majority of them played just behind Grabban. In my opinion it's not good enough I'm afraid. This is debate not criticism. I like the guy and I rate him but I am a bit underwhelmed with his Forest career so far. If his name was Dave Smith and we had signed him from Southampton he would be getting some right grief on here.

(19-10-2019, 01:32 PM)TheGreenMan Wrote:

(19-10-2019, 12:10 PM)Sniffer Dog Wrote:

(19-10-2019, 11:23 AM)TheGreenMan Wrote: Carvalho every day in his rightful position just behind Grabban.

Even tho I thought he had his best game for the club against Brentford since signing overall I think he’s been disappointing.
But to be fair to him he’s still getting used to playing in a foreign country and in a different type of league and we all know he has got that quality in him and I have every confidence in him that he’ll come good.

How much longer is that excuse going to be trotted out though?

I like Carvalho, I think he will play in the PL one day but right now I want to see more from him. 4 goals in 41 appearances the majority of them played just behind Grabban. In my opinion it's not good enough I'm afraid. This is debate not criticism. I like the guy and I rate him but I am a bit underwhelmed with his Forest career so far. If his name was Dave Smith and we had signed him from Southampton he would be getting some right grief on here.

I’m on about Silva(sorry I should’ve stated). 


And that’s a definitely criticism of Carvalho there.

(19-10-2019, 04:19 PM)Sniffer Dog Wrote:

(19-10-2019, 01:32 PM)TheGreenMan Wrote:

(19-10-2019, 12:10 PM)Sniffer Dog Wrote:

(19-10-2019, 11:23 AM)TheGreenMan Wrote: Carvalho every day in his rightful position just behind Grabban.

Even tho I thought he had his best game for the club against Brentford since signing overall I think he’s been disappointing.
But to be fair to him he’s still getting used to playing in a foreign country and in a different type of league and we all know he has got that quality in him and I have every confidence in him that he’ll come good.

How much longer is that excuse going to be trotted out though?

I like Carvalho, I think he will play in the PL one day but right now I want to see more from him. 4 goals in 41 appearances the majority of them played just behind Grabban. In my opinion it's not good enough I'm afraid. This is debate not criticism. I like the guy and I rate him but I am a bit underwhelmed with his Forest career so far. If his name was Dave Smith and we had signed him from Southampton he would be getting some right grief on here.

I’m on about Silva(sorry I should’ve stated). 


And that’s a definitely criticism of Carvalho there.

I think it's factual GreenMan not a criticism. Like I said I like the guy, I don't want to come across as a Carvalho hater because that is not the case at all.

(19-10-2019, 04:50 PM)the jock Wrote: Carvalho is obviously very talented but always feel he could do so much More. He dominated Middleborough in a terrific performance  last season but I can remember alot of mediocre performances too. He's not undroppable .