+- COYR NOTTINGHAM FOREST FORUM (https://coyrforestforum.co.uk)
+-- Forum: NOTTINGHAM FOREST - A REBEL CLUB IN A REBEL CITY (https://coyrforestforum.co.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=6)
+--- Forum: Nottingham Forest Fan Talk - Forest All Over The World (https://coyrforestforum.co.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=7)
+--- Thread: The Modern Day Goalkeeper (/showthread.php?tid=389)
The Modern Day Goalkeeper - GaribaldiRED - 08-01-2019
For those of you that are interested, I found a quite good article covering the 10 attributes a modern day goalkeeper should master.
The 10 attributes are:
- Shot-stopping
- Handling
- Reflexes
- Aerial command
- Big game ability
- Penalty-saving
- Distribution (feet)
- Distribution (arm)
- Sweeping
- The ultimate blend
How would you say our own Pants fits into the category of a modern day goalkeeper?
RE: The modern day goalkeeper - Duncan Mckenzie - 08-01-2019
In my opinion Pantilimon fails to fall into the category of a modern day goalkeeper based on those attributes!
RE: The Modern Day Goalkeeper - Paplane - 08-01-2019
Out of ten:
- Shot-stopping 6.5
- Handling 6
- Reflexes 7
- Aerial command 4
- Big game ability 6
- Penalty-saving 5
- Distribution (feet) 3
- Distribution (arm) 6
- Sweeping 6
- The ultimate blend 6.5
Not good enough or bang average at best.
RE: The Modern Day Goalkeeper - Sniffer Dog (Admin) - 08-01-2019
I would argue:
Handling 5.
Aerial command 3.
Summary, below average and a weak link.
RE: The Modern Day Goalkeeper - the jock - 08-01-2019
his distribution is his downfall. he has also left some pretty soft goals in during the year.
birmingham city fans are saying lee camp should get an england call up.
RE: The Modern Day Goalkeeper - Camms - 08-01-2019
(08-01-2019, 10:51 AM)the jock Wrote: his distribution is his downfall. he has also left some pretty soft goals in during the year.
birmingham city fans are saying lee camp should get an england call up.
Not just his distribution Jock. His command of his area for someone so tall is dreadful.
RE: The Modern Day Goalkeeper - the jock - 08-01-2019
(08-01-2019, 11:19 AM)Boatsy Wrote:(08-01-2019, 10:51 AM)the jock Wrote: his distribution is his downfall. he has also left some pretty soft goals in during the year.
birmingham city fans are saying lee camp should get an england call up.
Not just his distribution Jock. His command of his area for someone so tall is dreadful.
you are right boatsy i agree. no presence at all.
RE: The Modern Day Goalkeeper - GaribaldiRED - 08-01-2019
I agree with the comments made here and would like to add that I'm not at all impressed by his distribution and ball to feet. I would score him:
- Distribution (feet) 1
- Distribution (arm) 3
- Sweeping 2
- The ultimate blend 4.5 (compared to the big ones - Ederson, De Gea, Alisson)
RE: The Modern Day Goalkeeper - GaribaldiRED - 08-01-2019
I believe we are all very much in agreement when it comes to Pants but do anyone on this forum have any good suggestions of potential keeper targets that would manage a score above average and thus closer the what we would consider a modern day goalkeeper?
RE: The Modern Day Goalkeeper - GaribaldiRED - 08-01-2019
We have been linked with a loan move for Tom Heaton which obviously would be great but I doubt very much that he will want to leave. Has started the latest two Premier League games for Burnley (both won).
RE: The Modern Day Goalkeeper - Paplane - 08-01-2019
I honestly cant see what the problem is with Smith. Yes, I accept that he struggled with distribution, but he was expected, no he was required, by Warburton to try to play out from the back, even under a high press. Karanka would give him more flexibility to kick the ball long if he needed to. It's what Pants has been doing of late.
Smith would also be bolstered by having Fox / Dawson / Figs in front of him too. That'll make a huge difference.
He's got a season's experience in him so he cant be considered to be rookie any more and his shot stopping was excellent I thought (Ipswich worldy save for example). He's definately worth another shot IMO.
RE: The Modern Day Goalkeeper - Duncan Mckenzie - 08-01-2019
(08-01-2019, 11:50 AM)GaribaldiRED Wrote: I believe we are all very much in agreement when it comes to Pants but do anyone on this forum have any good suggestions of potential keeper targets that would manage a score above average and thus closer the what we would consider a modern day goalkeeper?
Bit difficult to answer that Gari.
I think its no secret now though that we are looking for a new keeper.
Rumours I have seen are Roberto, Heaton, Forster, Darlow and the chap from Man. City yesterday, a lot of smoke without to have any fire.