A Hit Or A Flop

[King Joe]

Newton - hit
Hennessy - hit
Bonalair - hit
Lyons - hit
Curran - hit
Gaynor - hit
Cormack - hit
Black - flop
Rogers - plank

[Sniffer Dog (Admin)]

Although jean-claude darchville was not a hit for us he signed for us at a bad time for himself,
he had lost his wife and kids in a car accident not long before so I wouldn't be to critical of him.

Thank you King Joe. I had forgotten about that.

[Strawberry Avenger]

Barry Lyons was just a fraction before my time but Terry Curran what a player. 100% Hit. I thought he was brilliant.

Wasn't he the difference between promotion for Brian Clough's Forest out of Division 2?

SA.

[JollyLolly]

Another couple from the distance past but again good pro footballers for Forest and brought for peanuts, George Lyall and Doug Fraser.

[Sniffer Dog (Admin)]

Barry Lyons was just a fraction before my time but Terry Curran what a player. 100% Hit. I thought he was brilliant.

Wasn't he the difference between promotion for Brian Clough's Forest out of Division 2?

SA.

He had a get season ripping opposing full backs apart.

[Sniffer Dog (Admin)]

This is an interesting one that might didvide opinion.

Grant Holt. Hit or Flop?

[Derby My Arse]

This is an interesting one that might didvide opinion.

Grant Holt. Hit or Flop?

For me he was a hit. In season 2009/07 Holt managed to score 18 goals despite starting many games on the bench.

If I remember well he was also voted player of the season.

[Alf Garnett]

Grant Holt - Hit but we could have and should have got so much more out of him.

[Sniffer Dog (Admin)]

Good points about Grant Holt above, hard to disagree.

Jim Brennan - Hit or Flop?

[Username]

This is an interesting one that might didvide opinion.

Grant Holt. Hit or Flop?

For me he was a hit. In season 2009/07 Holt managed to score 18 goals despite starting many games on the bench.

If I remember well he was also voted player of the season.

Calderwood played him as a winger for quite a few games too

[Duncan Mckenzie]

Good points about Grant Holt above, hard to disagree.

Jim Brennan - Hit or Flop?

For the record I will say he was a hit.

[Trent End Dave]

Grant Holt - hit for me. Went on to better things but did what he was brought in to do here.