A Hit Or A Flop

[Frochy1977]

Good points about Grant Holt above, hard to disagree.

Jim Brennan - Hit or Flop?

For the record I will say he was a hit.

Brennan was a hit for me. Think he played about 150 games over 4 or 5 seasons. Can't grumble.

[Username]

I agree on Brennan, we had some good players around that time.

[Sniffer Dog (Admin)]

What about Goalkeeper Paul Smith?

120 appearances over 6 years.

[ThePromisedLand]

Flop - if only he would’ve come off his line occasionally to take a cross.
How about Alan Davidson?

[Sniffer Dog (Admin)]

Agree on Smith. I thought he was poor the majority of his time with us.

My memory of Davidson is blurred so I won't comment on him.

[Username]

Smith broke records for us and was badly let down at times by inexperienced defending from Wilson, Morgan and Chambers.

Wilson was always a fraud in my eyes.

[Mad Squad]

Reading back through the thread here is my take on things so far.

Curran - Hit.
Holt - Hit.
John - Flop.
Brennan - Hit.
Smith - Flop.

[Sniffer Dog (Admin)]

Former Manchester United defender John Curtis who played 79 games for us between 2005-2007. That was the most number of games he played for any club during his career.

In my opinion he never lived up to his name and he was a very disappointing flop.

[Mad Mel]

I won't beat about the bush here. I thought John Curtis was crap.

Flop.

[Tricky]

I keep seeing this thread title and can't help thinking Phillipe Falop (flip flop lol)  :blush:

[King Joe]

Flop - if only he would’ve come off his line occasionally to take a cross.
How about Alan Davidson?

Alan Davidson only played a few games for us before having a Fit during a reserve match at the city ground, 
looked to be a promising full back but his illness if that's the right word held him back and he went back to oz.

[Sniffer Dog (Admin)]

I won't beat about the bush here. I thought John Curtis was crap.

Flop.

:) Stop sitting on the fence Robbo.