A Hit Or A Flop

[Salvatore Matrecano]

Marcus Tudgay

[Sniffer Dog (Admin)]

Christ, that's a good one SM.

I need to think about it for a bit.

[Ciscokid]

He'll always be remembered and loved for his 2 against the sheep but apart from that he's best forgotten.

[wassy04]

He had a good chant too for what that's worth

[McDurban]

Marcus Tudgay

I liked him, he scored a few decisive goals if I remember correctly.
I don't think he was brought it to lead the line either.
I'm going to be kind, neither a hit nor a flop.

[TheGreenMan]

Tudgay probably a hit just. Wasn’t spectacular, but did a decent job covering for Blackstock when he got injured.

[King Joe]

Looking at his career stats his best days were at sheff wed,
not great for us apart from the the 2 against the sheep but not a flop either.

[zicorice]

I always thought he looked ok, especially for a back up striker and sub. He was deceptively good in the air too. When I looked at his stats I reckon 2 things stand out. His 1 in 4 goal ratio is as good as you can realistically get as a back up striker. Then again, the only fee in his career was to us for 500k. Overall, going to have to say hit, if only because of the alleged role he played in the demise of George Burley as manager....

[Sniffer Dog (Admin)]

Having given Tudgay some thought I am voting hit but only just.

[Salvatore Matrecano]

My opinion is Flop with an honourable mention for the brace vs the sheep.
Still cant get over him starting the Swansea playoff match with Earnshaw on the bench.

[TheGreenMan]

My opinion is Flop with an honourable mention for the brace vs the sheep.
Still cant get over him starting the Swansea playoff match with Earnshaw on the bench.

Me neither, but only that corrupt manger of ours at the time would know the answer to that.

[Alf Garnett]

So that begs the question. Billy Davis hit or flop?